KEY TAKEAWAYS
- • Walter Ray Williams Jr. holds the all-time PBA record with 47 titles — the most ever.
- • Jason Belmonte holds the all-time record for major titles with 15, ahead of Anthony and Weber (10 each).
- • Era-adjusted earnings suggest earlier-era players were more financially dominant relative to their environment than raw figures show.
- • By the GOAT Score model used here, Walter Ray ranks #1 (102.5), followed by Belmonte (94.7), Weber (94.5), and Anthony (93.0).
- • EJ Tackett (68.5) is the highest-ranked active player in the model and the most likely next entrant in the GOAT conversation.
- • Greatest Career → Walter Ray Williams Jr. | Best Bowler Ever → Jason Belmonte.
If you hang around serious bowling fans long enough, the same argument always shows up:
"Who's the greatest of all time?"
Most people default to one stat — titles, majors, or maybe earnings — and pick their guy. That's easy. It's also incomplete.
If you actually want the real answer, you have to zoom out and look at:
- Total titles
- Major championships
- Career earnings (and era-adjusted earnings)
- Longevity
- Dominance vs. competition
- How difficult the era itself was
Once you do that, the answer gets a lot more interesting.
Part One
The Traditional GOAT Debate
There are dozens of greats, but the GOAT conversation realistically comes down to four:
Walter Ray Williams Jr.
Deadeye
102.5
GOAT Score
47
Titles
8
Majors
~$8.5M
Adj. Earnings
The most decorated champion in PBA history — 47 titles, 40 years, multiple generations.
Case For
- +Most titles ever (47)
- +Competed across multiple eras
- +Unmatched career longevity
Case Against
- −Fewer majors than Belmonte or Anthony
- −Less concentrated dominance than Anthony at peak
Bottom line: He's the most accomplished, but maybe not the most dominant.
Jason Belmonte
Belmo
94.7
GOAT Score
32
Titles
15
Majors
~$4.2M
Adj. Earnings
Revolutionized bowling with two hands and holds the all-time major record.
Case For
- +Most majors in history (15)
- +Dominates the most competitive modern era
- +Revolutionized technique for the entire sport
Case Against
- −Fewer total titles than Walter Ray, Anthony, or Weber
- −Benefits from higher modern prize pools
Bottom line: He's the most dominant modern player — and the most influential.
Pete Weber
PDW
94.5
GOAT Score
37
Titles
10
Majors
~$7M
Adj. Earnings
The sport's ultimate showman — clutch, televised, and decorated across 35 years.
Case For
- +10 major titles
- +Clutch, televised dominance
- +Spanned eras like Walter Ray
Case Against
- −Fewer total titles than Walter Ray
- −Less statistical dominance than Anthony at peak
Bottom line: If the question is "who do you trust in the 10th frame?" — it's Weber.
Earl Anthony
The Square
93
GOAT Score
43
Titles
10
Majors
~$5.5M
Adj. Earnings
He controlled the 1970s more completely than anyone has controlled any era since.
Case For
- +Dominated his era more than anyone
- +Double-digit majors (10)
- +Remarkable efficiency in a low-money era
Case Against
- −Played in a less complex equipment era
- −Shorter career window vs. Walter Ray or Weber
Bottom line: If you value dominance at peak, Anthony might be #1.
Context
The Era Problem: Why Most GOAT Arguments Fall Apart
Bowling is not the same sport across eras.
Then
Anthony era, early Weber
- ·Simpler lane conditions
- ·Less advanced equipment
- ·Lower scoring pace
- ·Smaller prize pools
Transitional
Walter Ray, late Weber
- ·Reactive resin changes everything
- ·Increased scoring
- ·More technical lane play
Now
Belmonte era
- ·Highly complex oil patterns
- ·Extreme rev rates
- ·Deep global talent pool
- ·Massive strategic depth
"When someone says 47 titles is greater than 32 titles, they may be ignoring difficulty of competition, complexity of conditions, and the evolution of the game."
Era Context
The Stat That Changes Everything: Era-Adjusted Earnings
When earnings are adjusted for inflation, earlier-era players gain significant ground and modern earnings compress by comparison. That suggests older players were often more dominant relative to their environment than raw money totals show.
| Bowler | Raw Earnings | Adj. to 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Walter Ray Williams Jr. | ~$4.9M | ~$8.5M |
| Jason Belmonte | ~$3.5M | ~$4.2M |
| Pete Weber | ~$4.0M | ~$7M |
| Earl Anthony | ~$1.0M | ~$5.5M |
All adjusted figures are estimates based on approximate CPI inflation calculations and are not official PBA data.
Part One Verdict
Who Is the GOAT? (Traditional View)
- Most Titles→ Walter Ray Williams Jr.
- Most Dominant Peak→ Earl Anthony
- Most Clutch→ Pete Weber
- Most Majors + Hardest Era→ Jason Belmonte
If you force one answer, Walter Ray Williams Jr. is the GOAT by career totals. But if you ask who the best bowler ever is, the answer shifts to Jason Belmonte.
Greatest Career
Walter Ray Williams Jr.
Greatest Bowler
Jason Belmonte
Part Two
The Modern GOAT Score
To move past gut-feel debates, we built a weighted scoring model that puts every era on the same scale. This section walks through the formula, applies it to all seven bowlers in this analysis, and shows what the numbers actually say.
The model includes three legends from the GOAT debate above plus three active PBA stars:
EDITOR'S NOTE — METHODOLOGY
The GOAT Score below is a weighted analytical framework, not an official PBA ranking system. Career averages and adjusted earnings figures are estimates sourced from official PBA records and CPI-adjusted calculations. The formula is designed to balance winning volume, major dominance, longevity, and era-adjusted financial context. All figures marked with (~) are estimates. Values labeled “Adj.” reflect approximate 2026 dollar equivalents.
THE GOAT SCORE FORMULA
GOAT Score =
(Titles × 1)
+ (Major Titles × 3)
+ (Adj. Career Earnings ÷ $1M)
+ (Years Active ÷ 2)
+ Career Avg Bonus:
220+ avg → +5
215–219 avg → +3
210–214 avg → +1
This is a weighted model for analytical purposes — not an official PBA ranking system. Values marked with (~) are estimates or era-adjusted figures. See Methodology section below.
The Data
GOAT Score Breakdown — All Seven Bowlers
| Rank | Bowler | Titles | Majors | Adj. Earnings | Longevity | Career Avg | GOAT Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Walter Ray Williams Jr. | 47 | 8 | ~$8.5M | 40 yrs | ~218 | 102.5 |
| 2 | Jason Belmonte | 32 | 15 | ~$4.2M | 17 yrs | ~222 | 94.7 |
| 3 | Pete Weber | 37 | 10 | ~$7M | 35 yrs | ~216 | 94.5 |
| 4 | Earl Anthony | 43 | 10 | ~$5.5M | 25 yrs | ~215 | 93 |
| 5 | EJ Tackett Active | 22 | 2 | ~$2.5M | 12 yrs | ~224 | 68.5 |
| 6 | Anthony Simonsen Active | 13 | 2 | ~$1.8M | 9 yrs | ~222 | 55.3 |
| 7 | Kyle Troup Active | 10 | 1 | ~$1.5M | 10 yrs | ~218 | 49 |
What It Means
How to Read These Numbers
Walter Ray Williams Jr. — 102.5
Still ranks #1 because of total body of work. No one else combines 47 titles, 40 years of competition, and era-adjusted earnings at that level. His lower major count (8) is the only real knock.
Jason Belmonte — 94.7
The closest challenger. Fifteen majors carry enormous weight in the formula (×3 each). His relatively short longevity window (17 years) is the gap holding him back from overtaking Walter Ray — and it may close.
Pete Weber — 94.5
Virtually tied with Belmonte. Weber's 35-year longevity gives him massive credit even with a lower career average. A legitimately underrated GOAT candidate.
Earl Anthony — 93.0
All four legends cluster within 10 points of each other. Anthony's shorter career window relative to Walter Ray and Weber holds him back despite 43 titles.
EJ Tackett — 68.5
The strongest current player in the model. His ~224 career average is the highest here, and his 22-title pace gives him a credible path. More longevity = more score.
Anthony Simonsen (55.3) and Kyle Troup (49.0)
Both are trajectory-based entries at this stage. Their scores reflect career work to date, not ceiling. Both have the average and the titles to move significantly — with time.
The Verdict
The Real Answer
GOAT (Career)
Walter Ray Williams Jr.
47 titles · GOAT Score: 102.5
Best Bowler Ever
Jason Belmonte
15 majors · Most influential delivery in history
Next Possible GOAT
EJ Tackett
Highest average in the model · Longest runway
The real value of this exercise is not just the opinion — it's the framework. Era-adjusted comparisons, career averages, and a structured scoring model give us a way to have a more honest conversation about greatness in bowling.
Every generation will have its own answer. Right now, the numbers say Walter Ray. But Belmonte keeps adding majors. And EJ Tackett is still bowling.
Born to Bowl Stars
The Future of the GOAT Conversation
EJ Tackett, Anthony Simonsen, and Kyle Troup — all featured in HBO's Born to Bowl docuseries — are included in this model not as all-time greats yet, but as the active players most likely to enter that conversation. Their profile pages on Bowlers Ltd. track their current stats.
EJ Tackett
GOAT Score: 68.5
The highest career average in the field and the biggest upside of any active player.
View profile →
Anthony Simonsen
GOAT Score: 55.3
Two-handed, decorated, and only 29 — the longest trajectory ahead of anyone in this field.
View profile →
Kyle Troup
GOAT Score: 49
The most recognizable face in bowling, with a brand that extends well beyond the lane.
View profile →
Transparency
Methodology & Sources
Title counts and major titles: Sourced from official PBA Tour records and player profiles. Figures reflect career totals through early 2026.
Career earnings: Raw figures sourced from official PBA career earnings data where available; some older figures are estimates based on historical records. Adjusted figures use approximate U.S. CPI multipliers to convert to 2026 dollars.
Career averages: All career average figures are approximate (~) estimates based on PBA statistical records and publicly reported averages. They are not official PBA certified averages.
GOAT Score model: This formula was developed by Bowlers Ltd. for editorial and analytical purposes. It is not endorsed by, affiliated with, or recognized by the PBA or any official bowling organization.
Data reviewed from: Official PBA website (pba.com), individual player official sites, PBA historical records, and publicly available career statistics. All era-adjusted figures are estimates.
Last reviewed: March 17, 2026. Stats will be updated as careers progress.
Common Questions
Bowling GOAT — Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the GOAT of bowling?+
By our five-factor GOAT Score — titles (×1), major titles (×3), adjusted career earnings (÷$1M), longevity in years (÷2), and a career average bonus — Walter Ray Williams Jr. scores 102.5, making him the statistical GOAT of professional bowling.
How many PBA titles does Walter Ray Williams Jr. have?+
Walter Ray Williams Jr. has 47 PBA Tour titles, the most of any professional bowler in history, along with 8 major titles and approximately $4.25 million in career earnings.
Who has the most PBA major titles?+
Jason Belmonte holds the all-time record for PBA major titles with 15, surpassing Earl Anthony and Pete Weber who each won 10 majors.
Is Jason Belmonte the GOAT of bowling?+
Many fans consider Belmonte the GOAT due to his record 15 major titles and revolutionary two-handed delivery. However, by total titles (32 vs. 47) and longevity (17 vs. 40 years), Walter Ray Williams Jr. holds a mathematical edge under most scoring systems.
Why is Walter Ray Williams Jr. considered the GOAT of bowling?+
Walter Ray Williams Jr. is widely considered the GOAT because he holds the all-time PBA record with 47 titles, competed across multiple generations, and accumulated era-adjusted career earnings estimated at approximately $8.5 million.
What is the GOAT Score formula for bowling?+
GOAT Score = (Titles × 1) + (Major Titles × 3) + (Adjusted Career Earnings ÷ $1M) + (Years Active ÷ 2) + Career Average Bonus (220+ = +5, 215–219 = +3, 210–214 = +1).
Who is the best active bowler in the PBA right now?+
Based on the GOAT Score model in this article, EJ Tackett ranks highest among current active players with 22 titles, 2 majors, and a career average near 224.
Can EJ Tackett, Anthony Simonsen, or Kyle Troup catch the all-time greats?+
All three active stars have exceptional averages and growing title counts, but are early in their longevity window. EJ Tackett (22 titles, GOAT Score 68.5) is the closest, but would need roughly 15–20 more years of elite production to challenge the top four.
Bowlers Ltd.
Roll in Style
Vintage bowling apparel for fans who appreciate the history of the sport.
Browse the Collection